Background

The retail sector signatories to the New Zealand Packaging Accord 2004 - 2009 believe that plastic shopping bags provide a cost-effective and practical means for distributing merchandise at point of sale in supermarkets and in the general retail environment. They often provide an important secondary use within homes for storage and ultimate removal of waste.

Plastic shopping bags are estimated to contribute less than 0.2% (by weight) to the entire waste stream in New Zealand. It is often the litter impact of plastic bags that contributes to the perception that they are a waste problem. By promoting to the public the responsible use of plastic shopping bags, the retail sector is striving to alleviate this litter problem.

Retail signatories to the Packaging Accord are committed to the responsible use of plastic shopping bags, including reducing unnecessary use of bags, providing reusable bag alternatives and collaborating with other sectors to promote the recovery and recycling of plastic shopping bags.

Under the Packaging Accord Brand Owners and Retailers Action Plan, the retailers have committed to a 20% reduction in plastic bag consumption by June 2009.

By 2007, these retailers had:

• reduced plastic bag consumption by 9.5% taking nearly 70 million bags out of use
• achieved an overall 15% reduction in the amount of plastic used
• achieved a 275% increase in sales of eco-bags

(New Zealand Packaging Accord Year Three Progress Report)

Make a Difference Campaign

On Tuesday 26th July 2007, Foodstuffs and Progressive Enterprises launched a joint campaign to Make a Difference to the environment by reducing the number of plastic bags used at their checkouts.

The launch was addressed by the then Minister for the Environment, Hon David Benson-Pope at an event in Wellington hosted by the New Zealand Retailers Association.

The new logo Make a Difference has been rolled out to 646 supermarkets and grocery outlets and reminds shoppers from the time they pick up their shopping trolley through to when they check out that they can choose whether to take a plastic bag.

Findings of the Australian Productivity Commission

Research commissioned by the Australian Government estimated:

• only 0.8% of plastic bags become litter;
• plastic bags account for 2% of all litter items (by number); and
• around 2% (or AUD$4 million) of annual expenditure on cleaning up litter is attributable to plastic bags.

Plastic-bag litter has the potential to injure marine wildlife, including endangered species. However, claims that at least 100 000 animals are killed each year by plastic-bag litter are not supported by evidence. Such claims appear to be based on the misinterpretation of Canadian research on the impact of fishing nets. Some have also misinterpreted case studies of individual animals that have come into contact with plastic debris (not just plastic bags) as being representative of the overall impact of plastic-bag litter. The true extent to which plastic-bag litter injures populations of marine wildlife, as opposed to individual animals, is likely to remain very uncertain because it is extremely difficult to measure [Finding 8.6].

Based on the evidence available to the Commission, it appears that the Australian, State and Territory Governments do not have a sound case for proceeding with their proposed phase out of plastic retail carry bags. Similarly, there does not appear to be a sound basis for the Victorian Government's proposed per-unit charge on plastic bags. A cost-benefit study commissioned by the Governments shows that the benefits of a phase out or a per-unit charge would be significantly outweighed by the costs. This is because the policies would penalise most uses of plastic retail carry bags, whereas the potential benefit would only come from the small proportion of bags that are littered. A more cost-effective approach would be to target littering directly [Finding 8.7].

(Productivity Commission 2006, Waste Management, Report no. 38, Canberra)

Click here to download the Productivity Commission's report.

Packaging Council Position

The Packaging Council does not support either a ban or a mandatory levy on plastic shopping bags. The Packaging Council fully supports the Make a Difference campaign and voluntary initiatives to achieve the commitment to reduce plastic bag consumption in New Zealand by 20% by June 2009.

This position is based on the following findings:

• Consumer research in 2007 by AC Neilson of 1000 typical shoppers in New Zealand, which showed that two thirds of all bags taken are being used for kitchen rubbish; 74% of respondents said they use plastic bags for their recycling; 1 in 4 put out plastic bags to be recycled; and 3 out of 4 New Zealanders don't support a ban on plastic shopping bags.
• International experience which shows there is a correlation between reduction in plastic shopping bags and an increase in the purchase of kitchen tidy bags or bin liners which tend to use heavier plastics resulting in more plastic disposed of to landfill.
• Plastic bags are a valuable raw material for recyclers because they are 'clean' plastic which can be easily made into pallets, underground cable covers and other plastic products. Some recyclers are importing plastic bags to meet demand.
• The findings of the Australian Productivity Commission.

Click here to download the AC Neilson consumer research.

Plastic bags are recognised as a small part of the waste to landfill problem and where concern is raised it tends to be specific to bags as a contribution to the overall litter problem. We believe that a ban on plastic bags makes no sense and are supportive of a holistic approach to tackling litter which is based on encouraging people to take personal responsibility.

Back to Top

TOWARDS SUSTAINABLE PACKAGING

77 Greenmount Drive, East Tamaki, Manukau
PO Box 58899, Greenmount, Auckland
PHONE 09 271 4044, FAX 09 271 4041
EMAIL: pac.nz@packaging.org.nz